..

/: ?

:
17.09.2010

() - , () - . - ? . . " " .

() , , .  , , , , , ,   - , . - , - -   , - "", ,  .

  " /", , . " " , " " , . [1] , , , , , , , , . [2] , , .

, , " ?" [3], , , ,   , " ". , , . [4] , " /", , , . , , , .[5]

, "" [6] [7], " /" . , , - . , - , [8] . , , - "" , , : , , .., , .

, , " /". , , , . . , , . : ? ? ? ? , " /" ? ?

, , .[9]

, 15:19-33. , - , , ( 15:24), . (17-26, ), . , , , , ( 12).

, . , " ": , [10], [11], , . , . ( 15: 1-18), [13] ,   , : , , . [15]

C " ". , 2- , , , " " (VIII,2) [16].

, ,   - , . , , , ( 7:15). "" "" [17] - , . , . [18] , o , : (, 2:20-22). ? . , " , ".[19]

"" "", ( 14). , "" (άγιος) "" [20], , ( 1:7; 6:1, 7:14; 2 1:1 ..)

. , :  .[21] , ( 15) .

, , " ", , 2- . , "" , . (300), (165) (253) "" " , , [22]; , "" .[23] : ", , - (), , ". , , , , " ", ., " ".[25]

[26], .[27] , , . , , , , "" .

. , , , , . , , , , , , .  , , , [28], [29], [30] [31]. 18:19 : "", , . , : " " ( 9:5), . [32] ,     - , , , . [33] , , . , , , , . [34] , , "" . [35] , 12 - . [36] , , , : , 2-   , , , . [37]

  , . [38] , 3- , , , . , , : " , , , , , ". , , :

" ,   , - . , ?"[39]

:

" , , , ; ". [40]

, , 9:20-22.

, o. 4- , " " , (105   ) 341 .. [41]    , (377). [42] -, , , . 1 : " , , , : ". [43] " " [44], , :

" , , , , : ". [45]

, , .[46] , -  , , , , "".  , - , - . 13- : " , , , , , : ". [47]

, , , , .

, , " /"? [48] , , , , - , . [49] e , e   - 2 (264), 262 ..:

" , , , . , , , , , . , 12 , , , . , , - . , , ".[50]

, , , . 9:20-22, : . , () . [51] , , . , - .[52] , , , [53]: , . , , , "katharoi". , , ,   "katharoi", "", , 325 .. [54]

  , : 12- ( 1159 ..), ,   ,   -  " ". [55] , ,   , ? " " , , : - , ? , , ? : , . [56] , : 40 . [57] , , , - ? ? , , "": 6-7 (381 ..), [58] 18 , . [59] , o , 2 , .

.

, "" 6-/ 7- .[60] , (590-604 ..), , () , . 601 , . , " ", (604)  , . :

" . , , . , , , , . , , , ?

C . (ex veneratione magna), (laudanda est); , (non judicanda). , .

, : , . , - . - . , . , , (videatur esse polluta) -

, e , , . [ ], , , , ". [61]

, . - - /.

, ,  . [62] 17- . [63]

" "

, " " - . -, , , . [64] .

"". 12- " " , , , . [65] , , , "", . , , , . . [66] , , . , 6 50- .[67] "", -, .[68]

, , " " " , , , , , ".[69]  , , c ? , . , "". , , , , . , , , , , .

40 , .   :

" , , , : .." [70]

, - . , , . ( ) , , "" (). : " , ".

 

, , , , . , 26 1997 , IV:

, , , .[71]

, 2000 :

, . , : ,


,   , , . [72]

e " ":

,   , , , , , , , . . [73]

, .. , 2- . , "" , , . - , . ( ) . , , "" (), - . , - .

, . 15 (. 363/364 .) 14 (787 .) . - , , . 22 23 , , , , , , . , , . 2- , 879 ., , . , . , . 69 (691/2 .) - - . , , . , . , , , - ?

, , . - - . , . , , Ÿ : , - , .

, . " " ,   . , / , . , , , , , . , . " " , .   .


:

1. - ( 1913), 1144.
2. . - . . : www.st-tatiana.ru/index.html?did=389 (15 January 2005). C. A. Klutschewsky, "Frauenrollen und Frauenrechte in der Russischen Orthodoxen Kirche," Kanon 17 (2005) 140-209.
3. :
" ?" 2 (2002) 24-26 : http://www.rocor.de/Vestnik/20022/.

4. . . : Book of Needs of the Holy Orthodox Church, trans. by G. Shann, (London 1894), 4-8.
5. . :www.russianchurchusa.org/SNCathedral/forum/D.asp?n=1097; www.ortho-rus.ru/cgi-bin/ns .
6. . (, , 1988). .
www.womenpriests.org/traditio/unclean.
7. , K. Anstall, "Male and Female He Created Them": An Examination of the Mystery of Human Gender in St. Maximos the Confessor Canadian Orthodox Seminary Studies in Gender and Human Sexuality 2 (Dewdney 1995), esp. 24-25.
8. C. G. Mantzaridis, Soziologie des Christentums (Berlin 1981), 129ff; id., Grundlinien christlicher Ethik (St. Ottilien 1998), 73.
9. , : E. Synek, Wer aber nicht völlig rein ist an Seele und Leib" Reinheitstabus im Orthodoxen Kirchenrecht," Kanon Sonderheft 1, (München-Egling a.d. Paar 2006).
10. E. Fehrle, Die kultische Keuschheit im Altertum in Religionsgeschichtliche Versuche und Vorarbeiten 6 (Gießen 1910), 95.
11. , 29.
12. , 37.
13. C. R. Taft, "Women at Church in Byzantium: Where, When - and Why?" Dumbarton Oaks Papers 52 (1998) 47.4
14. I. Be'er, "Blood Discharge: On Female Impurity in the Priestly Code and in Biblical Literature," in A.Brenne r (ed.), A Feminist Companion from Exodus to Deutoronomy (Sheffield 1994), 152-164.
15. J. Neusner, The Idea of Purity in Ancient Judaism (Leiden 1973).
16. M. James, The Apocryphal New Testament (Oxford 1926), 42. C. Taft, "Women" 47.
17. D. Wendebourg, "Die alttestamentli chen Reinheitsgesetze in der frühen Kirche," Zeitschrift20für Kirchengeschichte 95/2 (1984) 149-170.
18. C. Samariter," Pauly-Wissowa II, 1, 2108.
19. Matthaeum Homil. XXXI al. XXXII, PG 57, col. 371. 5 "" (?γιος) "" , ( 1: 7; 8: 27; 1 6: 1; 7: 14; 2 1: 1etc.)
20. Wendebourg, "Reinheitsgesetze" 150.
21. E. Synek, "Zur Rezeption Alttestamentlicher Reinheitsvorschriften ins Orthodoxe Kirchenrecht," Kanon 16 (2001) 29.
22. . Wendebourg, "Reinheitsgesetze" 153-155.
23. Justin, Dialog. 13; Origen, Contr. Cels. VIII 29.
24. V, 3. C. Wendebourg, "Reinheitsgesetze" 154.
25. Stromata III/XII 82, 6.6
26. . , . . Adv. Haer. 3. 22. 4. C. J. Behr, "Marriage and Asceticism," unpublished paper at the 5th International Theological Conference of the Russian Orthodox Church (Moscow Nov. 2007), 7.
27. J. Behr, Asceticism and Anthropology in Irenaeus and Clement (Oxford 2000), 171-184.
28. S. Stelzenberger, Die Beziehungen der frühchristlichen Sittenlehre zur Ethik der Stoa. Eine moralgeschichtliche Studie (München 1933), 405ff.
29. De monogamia VII 7, 9 (CCL 2, 1238, 48ff).
30. Div. Institutiones VI 23 (CSEL 567, 4 ff).
31. Paed. II/X 92, 1f (SC 108, 176f).
32. f. Behr, "Marriage and Asceticism," 7.
33. De exhortatione castitatis X 2-4 (CCL 15/2, 1029, 13ff). f. Wendebourg, "Reinheitsgesetze" 159.7
34. . .   D. I. Rankin, From Clement to Origen. The Social and Historical Context of the Church Fathers, (Aldershot-Burlington 2006), 113-140.
35. Cat.in Ep. ad Cor. XXXIV 124: C. Jenkins (ed.), "Origen on 1 Corinthians," Journal of Theological Studies 9 (1908) 502, 28-30.
36. Hom. in Lev. VIII 3f (GCS 29, 397, 12-15).
37. . L. W. Barnard, "The Background of Early Egyptian Christianity," Church Quarterly Rev. 164 (1963)
434; M. Grant, The Jews in the Roman World (London 1953), 117, 265. C. Wendebourg, "Reinheitsgesetze" 167.
38. . M. Simon, Recherches d'Histoire Judéo-Chrétenne (Pa ris 1962), 140ff., M. Grant, Jewish Christianity at Antioch in the Second Century," Judéo-Christianisme (Paris 1972) 97-108. C. Wendebourg, "Reinheitsgesetze" 167.8
39. Didaskalia XXVI. H. Achelis-J. Fleming (eds.), Die ältesten Quellen des orientalischen Kirchenrechts 2 (Leipzig 1904), 139.
40. 143.
41. . T. Tenšek, L'ascetismo nel Conci lio di Gangra: Eustazio di Sebaste nell'ambiente ascetico siriaco dell'Asia Minore nel IV secolo, Excerpta ex dissertatione ad Doctoratum in Facultae Theologiae Pontificiae Universitatis Gregorianae, (Rome 1991), 23-24.
42. J. Gribomont, "Le monachisme au IVe s. en Asie Mineure : de Gangres au messalianisme," Studia Patristica 2 (Berlin 1957), 400-415.
43. P. Joannou, Fonti. Discipline générale antique (IVe- IXes.), fasc. IX, (Grottaferrata-Rome 1962), t. I, 2,
89. (Pedalion) . (Chicago 1957), 523.
44. . Tenšek, L'ascetismo 17-28.9
45. Joannou, Discipline 91; The Rudder 524.
46. Tenšek, L'ascetismo 28.
47. Joannou, Discipline 94; The Rudder 527.
48. . P. Viscuso, Purity and Sexual Defilement in Late Byzantine Theology," Orientalia Christiana Periodica 57 (1991) 399-408.
49. f. H. Hunger, "Christliches und Nichtchristliches20im byzantinischen Eherecht," Österreichisches Archiv für Kirchenrecht 3 (1967) 305-325. 10
50. C. L. Feltoe (ed.), The Letters and Other Remains of Dionysius of Alexandria (Cambridge 1904), 102-
103. . P. Joannou, Discipline générale antique (IVe- IXes.) 1-2 (Grottaferratta-Rom 1962), 2, 12. 718.
51. , " " 24.
52. R. F . Taft, The Communion, Thanksgiving, and Concluding Rites (Rome202008), 205-207 (in press).
53. .  (ca. 1130/40-post 1195) : In epist. S. Dionysii Alexandrini ad Basilidem episcopum, can. 2, PG 138: 465C-468A.
54. Can. 8, Rallis-Potlis II, 133.
55. 719. " " 25.11
56. Klutschewsky, "Frauenrollen" 174.
57. . - . .  : www.st-tatiana.ru/index.html?did=389.
58. CPG 244; Joannou, Discipline II, 243-244, 264.
59. W. Riedel, Die Kirchenrechtsquellen des Patriarchats Alexandrien (Leipzig 1900), 209. See English translation in P. Bradshaw (ed.), The Canons of Hippolytus, English trans. by C. Bebawi (Bramcote 1987), 20. 0A

60. P. Browe, Beiträge zur Sexualethik des Mittelalters, Breslauer Studien zur historischen Theologie XXIII (Breslau 1932).   . H. Brodersen, Der Spender der Kommunion im Altertum und Mittelalter. Ein Beitrag zur Geschichte der Frömmigkeitshaltung, UMI Dissertation Services, (Ann Arbor 1994), 23-25, 132.12
61. PL 77, 1194 - 1195.

62. On the debate in the West as to whether menstruating women could take part in liturgical life see: J. Flandrin, Un Temps pour embrasser: Aux origines de la morale sexuelle occidentale (VIe-XIe s.) (Paris 1983), 11, 73-82.
63. , 14.
64. E. Levin, Sex and Society in the World of the Orthodox Slavs 900-1700 (Ithaca-London 1989), 46.
65. , VI (- 1908), 34,    46.13
66. .. XVI I XVII ( 2000), II, 2-3.
67. ( 1606), ff. 674v-675r. . Levin, Sex and Society 170.
68. ., ( 1998), 145-146, 3 5.
69. " ," ( 1906), 4v-5v.
70. " ," , 8 -9.14
71. Synek, "Wer aber nicht," 152.
72. 148.
73. Department of Religious Education, Orthodox Church in America (ed.), Women and Men in the Church. A Study on the Community of Women and Men in the Church (Syosset, New York 1980), 42-43.

(),

: http://kiev-orthodox.org/site/churchlife/2312/